What constitutes a “real” XML editor? The question is perennial, but is made topical by Tom Aldous’ surprisingly shrill defense of FrameMaker as an XML editor. It is unusual for a market-leading company to indulge in myth-busting aimed at tiny competitors. It is an approach more common to the small and desperate. But if we look past the oddness of Adobe employing this tactic, we see that the question of whether FrameMaker is a real XML editor, as with almost all debates about what makes a “real” anything, is not a debate about the product’s features, but a debate about what “real” means in the context.